The Reason We Learn
News • Education • Culture
A community of people working to improve education in America, one family at a time!
Interested? Want to learn more about the community?
March 23, 2022
The History of ESSA (and its fallout) You Don't Know

From 2015, but probably news to most. It's the WSJ, so in case you can't see it, here's the text:

Conservative reformers have had major successes, notably on welfare in 1996. But when a reform doesn’t turn out as hoped, they need to adapt. A case in point is No Child Left Behind, which the GOP Congress is now preparing to leave behind.

This week the House plans to debate the Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA), which lapsed in 2007 and needs revision. A bipartisan compromise has emerged from the Senate and House that isn’t perfect but would represent the largest devolution of federal control to the states in a quarter-century. It’s far better than the status quo that would continue if nothing passes.

No Child Left Behind, signed by George W. Bush in 2002, was the product of an imperfect union between Republicans who wanted more school accountability and Democrats who wanted more spending. In return for more federal funds, states were required to test students annually and report the results. One hundred percent of students were supposed to rate proficient by 2014, and failing schools were required to restructure under federal guidelines.

Yet few of the law’s goals have been achieved. Some states dumbed down standards so more students would pass the tests. Then the Obama Administration issued blanket waivers from the law’s mandates—but only if states adopted Education Secretary Arne Duncan’s prescriptions for teacher evaluations and common academic standards.

Washington’s heavy hand has produced a political backlash that crosses ideological lines, uniting teachers unions who want less accountability with Republicans who want less federal control. The ESEA compromise tries to accommodate this revolt by balancing federalism and accountability.

Gone are No Child Left Behind’s proficiency benchmarks and mandated federal interventions. The Education Department wouldn’t be able to prescribe accountability systems and standards. Yet importantly, the bill retains annual testing requirements for students from third to eighth grade (17 tests in total from K-12).

Testing in education is crucial to measure progress and ensure public accountability. Hence, states would have to publish test results disaggregated by race, socioeconomic status and disabilities. They would also have to create accountability systems for schools with the stipulation that quantitative measures outweigh qualitative judgments. This is so politicians can’t whitewash learning deficiencies.

A case in point is New York City where student achievement is merely one of seven criteria used to rate schools. The others are rigorous instruction, collaborative teachers, supportive environment, effective school leadership, strong family-communities ties and “trust”—all subjective matters that are easily gamed. Most of the 200 elementary and middle schools in which fewer than 10% of students pass state tests get good ratings, which hide the disparities between high-achieving charters and low-performing traditional schools.

States would also have to draft plans to rehabilitate their lowest-performing 5% of schools as well as those in which any group of students (e.g., low-income, special needs) consistently underperforms. In return, the bill would give states more funding flexibility by consolidating nearly 50 categorical grants for programs like physical education and Advanced Placement classes.

One disappointment is that the bill keeps “maintenance of effort” rules for state spending that can discourage efficiencies and labor reforms. There’s also no portability for Title I funds, which are designated for low-income students but flow to local public schools. Failing schools that lose kids to charters shouldn’t be rewarded by pocketing federal cash for the fleeing students. But there’s currently not enough support for voucherizing Title I funds in the Senate to overcome a Democratic filibuster.

Federal education spending would hew to the new budget caps, which upsets conservatives who correctly note that more money won’t improve learning. Between 2003 and 2013 total education expenditures rose by a third to $10,700 per pupil. But students in states that spend less like Florida ($8,647) and Tennessee ($8,208) have made bigger gains than kids in higher-spending one like New York ($19,818). Yet President Obama and Democrats would like to exceed the budget caps, so this spending restraint should be embraced.

The bill isn’t the complete devolution of power that conservatives would prefer, but it would help state reformers who want to do better. Since 2011 Ohio, Indiana and Wisconsin have enacted voucher programs. Florida, Tennessee and North Carolina have limited teacher tenure. Nevada this year established universal education savings accounts, which allow all parents to spend state funds on private school tuition, textbooks, tutoring and special services.

Republicans will have more chances to reform Washington’s role in education if they keep their majority, and this ESEA reauthorization expires in four years. They shouldn’t let their ideal of American federalism thwart a rare opportunity for real reform.

An earlier version misstated the total number of tests required from K-12.

Interested? Want to learn more about the community?
What else you may like…
Videos
Posts
August 13, 2022
Ray Raymond

If you missed the live, and are trying to decide whether to watch the show with Ray Raymond, here's a sample that I hope helps you decide!

00:02:25
June 23, 2022
It can now be revealed...

Here's the teaser for the show Tuesday! More details to come Monday, along with a link to the show. For now? This will be my first guest on the newly rebranded TRWL channel!

00:00:04
April 15, 2022
WELCOME TO NEW AND THANK YOU TO EXISTING MEMBERS AND SUPPORTERS!
00:03:32
February 01, 2024
New Collaboration Show With Kieran White!

Greetings! I wanted to make a plug for the new show Kieran White and I are doing each week on his YT channel! Here's this week's. Each week we cover three or four stories from the news, and ask the question: "Is that true?"

In this week's episode:
Neuralink: Is it turning us into cyborgs?
Deb: Am I really a racist?
Taylor Swift: Is she a DNC Op?

Watch here! Please subscribe and watch live, Wednesday at 2:00 PM Eastern.
https://www.youtube.com/live/XeCWcq47kzY?si=dItOJW-CdadrZLs5

January 10, 2024
Announcing the Launch of The Reason We Parent Support Group

I'm extremely proud to announce the launch of The Reason We Parent. Supporting parents towards solutions & away from obstacles.

This is a private & secure support group offering parents resources & advice.
Meetings twice each week, all Eastern times:
Wednesdays at NOON
Sundays 7:00 PM
How to join:
1. Use the link below to sign up for monthly or annual membership.
2. Login to your account and connect your DISCORD (if you don't have an account, you'll need to create one).
3. Turn on notifications for the server if you want to get reminders for each meeting!

Meetings will be max 2 hours, but members can drop in at any time within those timeframes.
These will be support calls via our private DISCORD server at Wokescreen.
Learn more at the link below!

https://wokescreen.com/the-reason-we-parent/

December 17, 2023
12 Days of Christmas Deals!

Kieran and I have been running specials each day for four days now (this is day 4), and today's may be of particular interest to those who've been waiting for a sale to become annual members!

Save 20% when you join either The Reason We Learn or the collaborative @wokescreen + The Reason We Learn community!

Support my work, build fellowship with like-minded people, access custom-curated resources to help you improve education for your own kids NOW, and become part of the solution!

This deal good through midnight EST 12/16! Tomorow there will be another special too!

If you're an existing member, you can upgrade to annual and use your new affiliate code to refer other new members and get paid when they join!!!

https://wokescreen.com/thereasonwelearn/

post photo preview
See More
Available on mobile and TV devices
google store google store app store app store
google store google store app tv store app tv store amazon store amazon store roku store roku store
Powered by Locals